Mozo logo

the mozo blog

Money musings, financial commentary plus the rambling wit and
wisdom of the team from Mozo - Australia's money info zone

Choice Shonkys put spotlight on rewards credit cards

Earlier this year we cracked the rewards code to reveal the value Australians were getting for their money with rewards credit cards with the launch of our Rewards Revealer tool. Today, consumer advocacy group, CHOICE, launched the 2010 CHOICE Shonkys, awarding the Commonwealth Bank Awards program a Shonky for low flying jest.

CHOICE singled out the Commonwealth Bank for its shonkiness in how the points are calculated for cards linked to the Qantas Frequent Flyer program. Unlike other rewards credit cards where one rewards point equals one Qantas Frequent Flyer Point, with the Commonwealth Bank card you only earn points at half the rate. It means you have to spend double the amount of money to earn the rewards.

The Shonkys, reminded us here at Mozo HQ of just how important the Rewards Revealer is, and so we decided to take this opportunity to take a look (and highlight) some other shoddy practices and unrewarding rewards programs.

Based on a $12,000 annual spend the three worst performing rewards cards are:

Card Annual rewards value minus fees
NAB Gold Card -$90
American Express Qantas American Express Premium Card -$74
Citibank Gold -$56

(excluding platinum cards)

Rewarding? Maybe for the banks but certainly not us consumers.

With the NAB Gold Card to earn you a flight from Sydney to London you’d need to spend a mind blowing $937,500 and that’s not the biggest catch. Points expire after 36 months, so unless you are planning on buying a house on your credit card, it’s virtually impossible to accrue enough points to redeem the flight before they expire.

But even more telling is that it’s not just a handful of rewards credit cards that will put you in the red. Of the 71 standard rewards cards in the market, 35 will cost you more than they return in rewards value each year (at $12,000 annual spend after the annual fee).

So, what can you do to ensure you get value from your rewards card? Here are our top tips:

1.    Make sure you are earning more in rewards than you are paying in annual fees
2.    Always pay off your card in full each month to avoid high interest rates
3.    If you have a credit card debt, switch to a low rate card instead

Compare rewards credit cards at mozo.com.au

Credit Cards – can you afford your reward?

What’s the real cost of frequent flyer miles or cashback points using a rewards credit card?

We’ve all fallen for the promise of free, see-through kitchen scales paid for by credit card rewards points, magical points. Because, let’s face it, we all know the allure of something for nothing, whereas the exchange rates for credit spend, points earned and rewards purchased are anything but transparent. So are you getting value for rewards points?

On behalf of everyone whose free return flight to Dubai is looking more like Dubbo, Mozo has cracked the rewards credit card code, to reveal the true value of all those points, cashback deals and discount programs.

The results are kinda scary, so deep breath.

We thought the main difference between the 100-plus different rewards credit cards would be how many toasters / flights / gift cards you get for your annual credit spend. But in many cases, the points expire before you can cash them in, or the rewards offered takes years to attain; worse still, the value of rewards earned is often less than the annual fee.

So how do you beat the rewards card market? Well, it all depends on your credit card spend — but our new Rewards Revealer lets you plug in your numbers for a personal solution. And you’ll find the results are wildly different for flights, giftcards and cashback offers.

If you spend $15,000 a year, the best rewards cards (determined by the value of rewards minus annual fees) are:

for gift cards: Myer Visa Card — $111
for cashback: American Express Blue Sky Credit Card — $103
for domestic flights: Jetstar Mastercard — $101
for international flights: Westpac Earth — $100

Whereas for $50,000 a year, it’s a completely different story:

for international flights: Citi Emirates Platinum — $1,021
for domestic flights: Jetstar Platinum Mastercard — $851
for gift cards: ANZ Rewards Gold — $621
for cashback: Westpac Altitude Platinum — $603

Remember, the interest rates on rewards credit cards nudge up to an outrageous 20%, so unless you pay off the whole balance every month, you’re unlikely to benefit from a rewards card.

Why not check out where your credit card ranks, or who gives you the most covetable appliances a year?

Get to the points at http://mozo.com.au/credit-cards/rewards.