Is superannuation a con?

Is superannuation a con?

With stock markets around the globe in free-fall this week, we asked the Mozo community what advice they had to protect hard earned super and savings. Mozo Answers Guru Katie responded with a provoking question of her own. We thought it was worth sharing with our blog readers, and wondered what other Australians think…

Is superannuation a con?

Many people are starting to wonder. Nothing can really protect people from the uncertainty of the stockmarket in relation to superannuation. Unfortunately, unless you are one of the really lucky few who are reaping the benefits in retirement from a (now unavailable) superannuation scheme that is indexed against the CPI on DEFINED BENEFITS, you will join the majority of us punters on the “Super Roller Coaster”!

The tax benefits, whilst substantial if you are prepared to stick it out for decades, may not offset the severe losses experienced by many in a undulating market which has set some people back to the same level they were on five years ago!

If you do the math and invested $200,000 in a term deposit five years ago at the, then, available 8% you would be $80,000 better off even when you deduct tax. Whilst the gains MAY be made over 30+ years, the share market (forming the base of superannuation investment) is a gamble. Of course, one must NEVER change their options or attempt to withdraw Super when it is at its lowest as it will compound your losses severely. However, I really do believe that Super is over-hyped and under-performing.

The REAL danger with Super is that it is also subject to ongoing political interference. Don’t be surprised if, in the near future, the federal government will prevent anyone from taking LUMP SUMS and change the laws so that everyone will need to eke out a pension. As huge numbers of Baby Boomers are retiring, the federal government will be prodding and poking away at the methods of superannuation payments to ensure they will not have the burden of paying out massive lump sums over time.

Personally, I believe that it is preferable to invest in an investment property over time which, at least, will provide you with a steady rental income. Alternatively, take the lump sum as soon as you hit 60 (or 65) and put it in a Term Deposit. The HIGHS may not be as good as the occasional uplift in Super, but you can sit on the money (without worry) and sleep at night knowing exactly how much you are going to get each month.

That means a lot when you’re retired – who needs the stress?

Is superannuation a con? was last modified: June 26, 2015 by Mozo

Share This Post

3 Comments - Write a Comment

  1. I think you don’t understand the tax effectiveness of super before and after age pension age, nor how it can be used to maximise age pension entitlements.

    Probably not a good idea to provide advice on a site like this because it is likely that you will not be covered in the event that someone takes your advice literally and stuffs up.

    Reply
  2. I have to agree that it is a necessary evil. None of us want to be eating catfood when we’re old!
    My recent experience with an unsolicited superfund was pretty frustrating – in a time where identity theft is such a major concern an account was set up in my name TWICE without a single contact being made with me to confirm it’s validity – the second account was being set up as the first was being closed!
    Can we really trust our future to this sort of ‘management’?
    My advice, Do it yourself, a term deposit is much more secure and doesnt fly itself around the world first class in an armani suit with your money…

    Reply
  3. I cashed in my superannuation years ago and it was the best thing I ever did. My colleagues have suffered with poor returns and endless worries. A real con in my opinion and I’m glad I’m well out of it.

    Reply

Post Comment